Everton Eye Shock Reunion with John Stones as New Stadium Era Looms
Everton are reportedly plotting a sensational move to bring Manchester City defender John Stones back to Goodison Park this summer, a transfer that could mark a bold statement of intent as the club prepares for their relocation to the state-of-the-art Bramley-Moore Dock stadium in the 2025/26 season. Stones, a former Everton star from 2013 to 2016, has struggled for consistent game time at Manchester City due to persistent injuries, prompting speculation about his future. With his contract set to expire in 2026, Everton see an opportunity to re-sign the 30-year-old England international, but the move is not without significant risks.
Stones was a fan favorite during his Everton tenure, making 95 appearances and earning a £50 million move to Manchester City in 2016. Since then, he has enjoyed a glittering career, winning six Premier League titles, two FA Cups, and a Champions League trophy under Pep Guardiola. However, injuries have plagued his recent seasons, limiting him to just 11 Premier League starts this term and fewer than 10 in each of the last two campaigns. A recurring thigh injury may require surgery, further clouding his prospects at City, where he has fallen behind defenders like Rúben Dias, Manuel Akanji, and Nathan Aké in the pecking order. Transfer insider Graeme Bailey has suggested that City are open to letting Stones go as part of a defensive overhaul, with Everton’s David Moyes—back at the helm—keen to capitalize on the situation.
Speculation is rife about a potential swap deal between Manchester City and Everton involving John Stones and Jarrad Branthwaite. With Stones’ contract nearing its 2026 expiry and his role at City uncertain, Everton are keen to bring back their former defender. In exchange, City have their sights on Branthwaite, the 22-year-old centre-back valued at £75 million, seen as a long-term successor to Stones. The deal could benefit both clubs, with Everton softening the loss of Branthwaite and City securing a promising talent. While no agreement is confirmed, the proposed swap has sparked intrigue among Premier League fans.
For Everton, re-signing Stones would be a marquee addition, aligning with their ambition to elevate the squad for their new stadium era. The Toffees have endured financial challenges and mid-table finishes in recent years, but the prospect of a new home has injected optimism. Stones’ experience, versatility, and familiarity with the club make him an appealing target. His ball-playing ability, honed under Guardiola, could complement Everton’s defensive options, including young star Jarrad Branthwaite. However, the financial and physical risks are substantial. Stones earns £250,000 per week, a significant outlay for Everton, and his injury record raises concerns about his reliability. Fans on X are divided: some see a romantic homecoming for a proven winner, while others fear a costly gamble on a player past his peak.
Complicating matters, Everton face competition from West Ham, Brighton, Juventus, and Saudi Pro League clubs, all reportedly monitoring Stones’ situation. Meanwhile, Manchester City have been linked with Branthwaite as a potential replacement, creating an intriguing transfer dynamic between the clubs. Everton’s pursuit of Stones would require careful negotiation, likely at a reduced fee given his contract status, but his wages and medical history will be sticking points.
