Manchester City Fans Call for Kalvin Phillips’ Sale Amid Leeds United Transfer Speculation
Manchester City fans have recently taken to social media, particularly platforms like X, to voice their frustrations with midfielder Kalvin Phillips, with many urging the club to sell the 29-year-old following a deleted Instagram post that sparked controversy. The England international, who joined City from Leeds United in 2022 for a reported £42 million (potentially rising to £45 million with add-ons), has struggled to secure a consistent role under Pep Guardiola. His lackluster performances during loan spells at West Ham United and Ipswich Town, combined with the now-deleted social media post, have fueled speculation about his future, with some suggesting a return to his boyhood club, Leeds United.
Phillips’ time at Manchester City has been marred by limited game time and persistent injury issues. Since his arrival, he has made just six starts for the Premier League champions, with only 14 minutes of league action in his debut season due to a shoulder injury and subsequent fitness concerns. Notably, Guardiola publicly criticized Phillips for returning from the 2022 World Cup overweight, a comment for which he later apologized. Despite being part of City’s historic treble-winning squad in 2022-23, Phillips’ inability to adapt to Guardiola’s tactical demands—particularly the need for a disciplined holding midfielder who excels under pressure—has left him on the fringes. His loan moves to West Ham and Ipswich were intended to revive his career, but neither stint has yielded the desired impact. At Ipswich, Phillips has featured in 20 matches this season but has failed to establish himself as a key player, prompting further scrutiny.
The controversy surrounding Phillips intensified when he reportedly posted, then quickly deleted, an Instagram update hinting at his dissatisfaction with his current situation. While the exact content of the post remains unclear, it was enough to ignite a firestorm among City fans. On platforms like Reddit and X, supporters expressed their disappointment, with sentiments like “Leeds can have him even if they don’t get promoted” and calls for the club to “cut their losses” on the midfielder. Many fans feel Phillips, despite his undeniable talent, does not fit City’s system, with one user noting, “He’s a good player, but not for Pep’s style. Sell him and move on.” The deleted post, perceived as unprofessional, only amplified these calls, with fans questioning his commitment.
Amid this backlash, transfer rumors have linked Phillips with a sensational return to Leeds United, where he rose through the academy and became a fan favorite under Marcelo Bielsa. Sources, including Football Insider, report that Phillips is pushing for a move back to Elland Road, especially if Leeds secure promotion to the Premier League. The club, currently managed by Daniel Farke, sees Phillips as a potential boost to their midfield, offering him the chance to rediscover the form that earned him 31 England caps. However, any deal would likely see City take a significant financial hit, given the original transfer fee.
For Phillips, a return to Leeds could be a chance to rebuild his career and regain his England spot. For City fans, however, the consensus is clear: it’s time to part ways. As transfer speculation grows, Phillips’ next move will be pivotal for all parties involved.
Word count: 498
Sources:,,,,
Sources:,,,,
