Ally McCoist Criticizes Rangers’ Appointment of Russell Martin, Club Responds
Rangers legend Ally McCoist has publicly slammed the club’s decision to appoint Russell Martin as their new head coach, labeling the move “underwhelming” and expressing concerns over Martin’s rigid tactical approach. The former Southampton boss was confirmed as Rangers’ manager on a three-year deal, following a US-led takeover by Andrew Cavenagh and 49ers Enterprises. However, McCoist’s remarks have sparked debate among fans and pundits alike.
Speaking on talkSPORT, McCoist, Rangers’ record goalscorer, voiced his unease after witnessing Martin’s Southampton side struggle in the Premier League, particularly highlighting a chaotic 3-0 defeat to Brentford. “It was absolute carnage,” McCoist said, describing Martin’s insistence on playing out from the back as “mentally scarring.” He urged fans to give Martin a chance but admitted the appointment felt lackluster, especially with high-profile names like Davide Ancelotti and Steven Gerrard previously linked. “It’s imperative the club moves fast, but this feels underwhelming. He’s got to adapt,” McCoist added, emphasizing the need for flexibility in the Scottish Premiership’s high-pressure environment.
Martin, who briefly played for Rangers on loan in 2018, has a reputation for possession-based football, influenced by Pep Guardiola. His successful promotion with Southampton via the playoffs was overshadowed by a torrid Premier League campaign, leading to his sacking in December 2024. McCoist’s comments echo concerns among some Rangers supporters, who fear Martin’s style may not suit the squad or the demands of challenging Celtic for the title.
In response, Rangers issued a statement defending their choice. “We conducted a thorough process, and Russell Martin emerged as the standout candidate,” said sporting director Kevin Thelwell. “His vision for attacking, dominant football aligns with our ambitions. We believe he will build a winning culture at Ibrox.” The club also highlighted Martin’s leadership qualities and track record of developing players, dismissing concerns about his brief playing stint as irrelevant to his managerial credentials.
As Rangers prepare for crucial Champions League qualifiers, Martin faces immediate pressure to prove his doubters, including McCoist, wrong. With the club’s new owners backing him, the coming months will determine whether Martin can silence critics and restore Rangers’ dominance in Scottish football.
