Carragher’s Controversial Claim: Ferguson’s Brutal Approach Questioned by Boyd Ahead of Celtic Clash
As the Scottish Premiership braces for another explosive Old Firm derby between Rangers and Celtic, former Liverpool star Jamie Carragher has sparked a heated debate with bold claims about Rangers interim manager Barry Ferguson’s methods. Carragher, known for his outspoken punditry, suggested that Ferguson might resort to “brutal” measures to prepare his players for the high-stakes clash at Parkhead. However, Rangers legend Kris Boyd has vehemently disagreed, dismissing Carragher’s remarks as out of touch and defending Ferguson’s leadership
Speaking on Sky Sports’ coverage ahead of the Celtic vs. Rangers showdown, Carragher painted a vivid picture of Ferguson’s approach to motivating his squad. Drawing on his own experiences in high-pressure derbies, Carragher speculated that Ferguson, known for his fiery personality and uncompromising attitude as a player, might be pushing his players to their limits—both mentally and physically—to ensure they’re ready for the cauldron of Celtic Park.
“Barry Ferguson’s a proper old-school character,” Carragher said. “You can imagine him in that dressing room, doing some brutal things to get his players up for this game—maybe a few choice words, maybe even shaking them up physically to fire them up. This is the Old Firm; it’s not just tactics, it’s about passion and intimidation.”
Carragher’s comments appeared to reference Ferguson’s reputation as a hard-nosed midfielder who led Rangers with intensity during his playing days. The pundit suggested that Ferguson might lean into that persona to galvanize a Rangers side desperate to close the gap on league leaders Celtic, who are on the verge of securing the title. With Rangers coming off a disappointing 2-0 loss to Hibs, Carragher argued that Ferguson might need to take extreme measures to avoid another setback.
Kris Boyd, a former Rangers striker and Ferguson’s teammate during their time at Ibrox, was quick to shut down Carragher’s claims. Speaking on the same Sky Sports panel, Boyd defended his former captain, insisting that Ferguson’s approach is far more measured and professional than Carragher’s “brutal” characterization suggests.
“That’s absolute nonsense from Jamie,” Boyd fired back. “Barry’s not in there throwing punches or screaming like some madman. He’s a leader who knows how to get the best out of his players with respect and clarity. He’s not about brutal stuff—he’s about building belief and getting the tactics right. To suggest otherwise is just lazy stereotyping.”
Boyd, who has been a vocal supporter of Ferguson’s interim tenure, pointed to Rangers’ recent successes under the 47-year-old, including a thrilling Europa League quarter-final qualification and a morale-boosting Old Firm win earlier in the season. He argued that Ferguson’s ability to inspire his squad comes from his deep understanding of the club and the rivalry, not from outdated or aggressive tactics.
“Barry’s been there and done it as a player,” Boyd added. “He knows what it takes to win at Celtic Park. He’s not going to risk alienating his players with some over-the-top approach. He’s smarter than that, and the results speak for themselves.”
Carragher’s comments may also reflect the broader narrative surrounding the Old Firm rivalry, where passion and intensity often overshadow tactical nuance. His suggestion of “brutal” methods could be seen as a nod to the physical, confrontational style that once defined these encounters, particularly during Ferguson’s playing era in the early 2000s. However, Boyd’s rebuttal aligns with a modern footballing ethos, where managers like Ferguson must balance motivation with discipline in an increasingly professional game.
Since taking over as interim boss following Philippe Clement’s departure, Ferguson has shown a knack for rallying Rangers during big moments. His side’s Europa League progress and a previous Old Firm victory over Celtic in March 2025 have earned him praise, with Boyd even hailing him as “the leader Rangers need.” However, inconsistency has plagued Rangers, and Celtic’s dominance under Brendan Rodgers remains a formidable challenge.
Ferguson’s approach to the upcoming Celtic game will likely focus on neutralizing key threats like Daizen Maeda, who has tormented Rangers’ defense in past encounters. Boyd has previously expressed concerns about Celtic exploiting Rangers’ full-backs, suggesting that Ferguson’s tactical adjustments will be crucial. Carragher’s talk of “brutal” preparation, meanwhile, seems to overlook these finer details in favor of a more sensational
For Celtic fans, the debate adds extra spice to an already mouthwatering fixture. Social media posts on X have seen supporters revel in the prospect of Boyd’s frustration if Celtic secure the title, with some cheekily referencing his history of “seething” during their victories. Meanwhile, Rangers fans have rallied behind Boyd’s stance, praising his loyalty to Ferguson and his rejection of Carragher’s “English pundit” perspective.
As Rangers prepare to face Celtic, the focus should remain on the pitch, where Ferguson’s leadership will be tested against a relentless Celtic side. Jamie Carragher’s claim that Ferguson might employ “brutal” tactics has been firmly debunked by Kris Boyd, who insists his former teammate is a calculated and inspiring figure. Whether Ferguson’s methods are fiery or composed, one thing is certain: the Old Firm derby will deliver its trademark drama, and the result could shape the narrative for both clubs in the race for Scottish football supremacy.
