Scottish Cup Final 2026: Celtic Win the Double, But VAR Steals the Headline — Again
Celtic lifted the Scottish Cup at Hampden Park on Saturday, beating Dunfermline Athletic 3-1 to complete a domestic double. Martin O’Neill signed off in style. Neil Lennon’s fairytale underdog run came up short. And somehow, the loudest conversation after the final whistle had nothing to do with any of that.
It was about a handball. From last week.
Celtic were the overwhelming favourites going in, and they delivered. Arne Engels was outstanding, firing a powerful strike from outside the box to put Celtic in control. The Hoops looked composed, dominant, and well-organised throughout.
Dunfermline, managed by former Celtic boss Neil Lennon, showed real heart. They had beaten Queen of the South, Hibernian, Kelty Hearts, Aberdeen, and Falkirk to get to this point — a remarkable run for a Championship side. On the day though, the gap in quality told. Celtic led 3-0 before Josh Cooper grabbed a late rebound consolation to make it 3-1.
There was one moment that raised eyebrows — a Celtic goal disallowed for offside after Kelechi Iheanacho converted a Yang Hyun-Jun pass. It didn’t change the outcome, but given the climate around Scottish officiating right now, it did not go unnoticed.
To understand why refereeing dominated the conversation around this final, you have to go back to the week before.
In the 97th minute of Celtic’s title-decider at Motherwell, referee John Beaton was sent to the VAR monitor and awarded Celtic a penalty for a Sam Nicholson handball. Iheanacho scored. Celtic won 3-2 and kept their title hopes alive — hopes they fulfilled the following Saturday by beating Hearts.
The reaction was immediate and fierce.
Ally McCoist called it a “horrendous decision” that had “embarrassed Scottish football” and called for VAR to be scrapped entirely in Scotland. Kris Boyd backed him up on Sky Sports, pointing out that the ball had gone back out of the penalty area — questioning the very logic of the call.
Chris Sutton disagreed. He argued the fury was not really about the decision at all, but about who benefited from it. His view: the outrage was fuelled by anti-Celtic bias, plain and simple.
That argument was still running hot by the time Saturday’s final kicked off.
The SFA appointed experienced referee Steven McLean for the final, with Matthew MacDermid on VAR duty — a deliberate choice given how much scrutiny officials have been under. Before a ball was kicked, pundits were already noting that refereeing decisions had been “a topic of heavy discussion” across Celtic’s recent games.
That context made every decision at Hampden feel loaded.
Celtic deserved their double. O’Neill leaves as a champion. Dunfermline’s cup run was one of the stories of the season.
But Scottish football has a VAR problem it cannot ignore. When the arguing about a penalty from the previous week drowns out a cup final, something has gone seriously wrong — and no amount of silverware will change that conversation.
About the Author
