Following Everton’s 0-2 loss to Manchester City on April 19, 2025, Everton fans expressed significant frustration and disappointment, particularly focusing on individual player performances and tactical decisions. Key points from fan reactions on X include:
-
Criticism of Michael Keane: Fans heavily criticized defender Michael Keane, with some calling his performance a “nightmare” and blaming him for defensive errors leading to City’s goals. One fan stated, “Michael Keane should never wear an Everton shirt again,” reflecting the intensity of the backlash. Others linked his performance to broader defensive concerns, with comments like “Keane has no defence awareness.”
-
Impact of James Tarkowski’s Injury: The injury to key defender James Tarkowski was seen as a turning point, with fans noting it “completely killed” Everton’s defensive stability. Many expressed hope for his quick recovery, as his absence forced Keane into the lineup, which fans felt exposed Everton’s weaknesses.
-
Disappointment with Substitutions: Fans questioned manager David Moyes’ tactical decisions, particularly the triple substitution that included removing Idrissa Gana Gueye. They felt these changes disrupted Everton’s rhythm, with one fan stating, “The triple substitution killed us as we were playing good football.” Another described the replacements, including Keane, as “awful.”
-
Missed Opportunities and Overall Performance: Some fans acknowledged Everton had two good chances but failed to capitalize, leading to a “boring game” where “tired legs got the better of us.” While some felt Everton held their own against City’s possession, others believed the team could have secured a point without the defensive lapses.
-
Selection Choices: There was discontent over starting Armando Broja over Beto, with fans believing this was a tactical error that weakened Everton’s attack.
Overall, Everton fans were vocal about their frustration with Keane’s performance, Moyes’ substitutions, and the impact of Tarkowski’s injury, viewing these as critical factors in the loss. Despite the defeat, some fans remained optimistic, urging the team to “move on” to the next match.
