Why Leeds United Are Poised to Pass on Kalvin Phillips’ Return
Leeds United’s decision to forego re-signing their former star Kalvin Phillips has sparked debate among fans, with the underlying reasons now coming into focus. Despite Phillips’ storied history with the club and his openness to a return, Leeds appear set to prioritize pragmatism over sentimentality.
Phillips, a homegrown hero, was pivotal in Leeds’ 2020 Championship promotion and their Premier League consolidation under Marcelo Bielsa. His £42m transfer to Manchester City in 2022 promised greatness, but limited minutes at City and lackluster loans at West Ham and Ipswich Town have dimmed his star. Now 29, Phillips is eager to rediscover his form, and a return to Elland Road—where he earned England call-ups—seemed a perfect fit, especially with Leeds’ Premier League return confirmed for 2025/26.
Yet, financial realities are the biggest hurdle. Phillips’ £10m-a-year wages at Manchester City dwarf Leeds’ current pay structure, creating a significant obstacle. Even a reduced salary would strain the club’s budget, particularly under the scrutiny of Profitability and Sustainability Rules (PSR). Manchester City’s reported £20m valuation further complicates matters, as Leeds view it as inflated for a player whose recent performances have been inconsistent.
Tactically, Leeds also have reservations. Manager Daniel Farke’s midfield is well-served by versatile players like Ethan Ampadu, and there are concerns about Phillips’ fit in the current system. Pundits, including Leeds icon Eddie Gray, have noted that Phillips’ dynamism has waned since his departure, raising doubts about his ability to meet the Premier League’s demands. With survival the priority, Leeds are reluctant to gamble on a player whose best days may be behind him.
The emotional pull of Phillips’ return is strong—evidenced by his recent social media nod to Leeds’ Dan James—but the club’s recruitment strategy is laser-focused on sustainability. Leeds are eyeing targets like Borussia Monchengladbach’s Julian Weigl to bolster their squad with fresh, cost-effective talent. While fans may yearn for a nostalgic homecoming, Leeds’ decision to pass on Phillips underscores a commitment to ruthless, forward-looking choices to secure their Premier League future.
