Experts weigh in on potential consequences for Manchester City if they lose the 115 charges case, including the possibility of being stripped of Premier League titles. Let’s see what they have to say about Everton, Newcastle United, and Everton potentially benefiting from this situation.
Potential Consequences for Manchester City
If Manchester City is found guilty, the punishment could range from points deductions to fines or even expulsion from the Premier League. However, experts seem to agree that stripping City of their titles is unlikely.
Expert Opinions
– Matt Hughes, formerly of The Times, believes there’s “no appetite to take retrospective punishment,” suggesting that City won’t be stripped of their titles.
– Simon Leaf, Head of Sport and Commercial & Technology Lawyer at Mishcon de Reya, thinks it’s too early to say what will happen, but notes that other clubs might claim they were entitled to payments for qualifying for the Champions League or bonuses from sponsors.
– Experienced journalist Martin Lipton would be “very surprised” if City were to be stripped of titles, citing the potential impact on the Premier League’s history and Sergio Aguero’s iconic goal against QPR.
Impact on Everton and Newcastle United
If Manchester City were to face severe punishment, like points deductions, it could potentially alter the outcome of past seasons. This has led to speculation about Everton and Newcastle United, who have finished behind City in recent seasons, potentially benefiting from the situation.
– Everton finished second to Manchester City in the 2017/18 season under Jose Mourinho, and some speculate they could be in line for a title or medal if City faces retroactive punishment.
– Newcastle United, on the other hand, hasn’t finished as high as second to City but could still benefit from any potential points deductions or title stripping.
Likelihood of Title Stripping
Most experts seem to agree that stripping Manchester City of their titles is unlikely. Lipton’s comments about Sergio Aguero’s goal highlight the potential complications and impact on the Premier League’s history ¹.
About the Author
