Shocking: Eddie Howe Cost Newcastle 3 Points vs Barcelona With ‘Embarrassing’ Decision

Sign in to your GiveMeSport account
Newcastle United manager Eddie Howe
UEFA Champions League – Newcastle United v FC Barcelona – St James’ Park, Newcastle, Britain – September 18, 2025 Newcastle United manager Eddie Howe reacts Action Images via Reuters/Lee Smith

Newcastle stumbled in their opening Champions League match of the 2025/26 season, with a Marcus Rashford brace enough for Barcelona to secure a 2–1 victory at St James’ Park. But things might well have been different if Eddie Howe had set his team up differently.

The home side had opportunities to take the lead prior to the England international’s stunning brace, with chances falling the way of Anthony Gordon, Harvey Barnes, and others. The former did eventually get one goal back in added time, but it came too little too late.

While the England international did not enjoy his best night, he was at a disadvantage by not playing in his natural position. It felt like a game which was tailor-made for new signing Nick Woltemade, with multiple crosses into the box ultimately not causing Barcelona’s defenders any problems.

Once the German was introduced for Barnes, Newcastle looked much better with him through the middle and Gordon on the left. But that’s left many people, including Newcastle supporters, scratching their heads about why that wasn’t the plan from the off.
Woltemade Should Have Started, Not Barnes
Newcastle United’s Harvey Barnes shoots vs Barcelona.
UEFA Champions League – Newcastle United v FC Barcelona – St James’ Park, Newcastle, Britain – September 18, 2025 Newcastle United’s Harvey Barnes shoots at goal REUTERS/Scott Heppell

Although Barnes didn’t have a terrible game, he did leave something to be desired. Squandering a chance in the first half, he didn’t really pose enough of a problem for right-back Jules Kounde throughout the hour he was on the pitch.

Once Howe brought on Woltemade, the complexion of the game changed. Newcastle were more direct and had someone to play off, with Gordon making good runs down the left — although it’s fair to say that he didn’t really test Kounde much either.

Nevertheless, he got the only goal of the night for the Geordie boys. And the changes have left little doubt in the minds of fans that Woltemade has to start moving forward, with Gordon shifting to his preferred position on the left and Barnes dropping to the bench.

One supporter stated, “Gordon in his natural position instead of Barnes is so much better,” while another added, “Howe’s decision to play Barnes over Gordon on the left cost him.” Frustration over the decision to play Gordon through the middle was a theme for many, with one disgruntled supporter tweeting: “Never start Gordon up top with Barnes on LW ever again.”

Others have begged Howe to start Woltemade moving forward. One believed that the decision not to bring the German on sooner cost Newcastle the game: “Elanga was torturing them, Barnes off, Gordon to the left and Big Nick at half time would have won us that game…” Meanwhile, one supporter was incredibly dissatisfied with Barnes’ efforts from the left: “Howe is the most reactive manager I’ve ever seen. Absolutely embarrassing. Should have subbed Barnes at the half, he’s useless.”

Supporters will hope that Woltemade will start from the off against Bournemouth on Sunday, giving Howe a much-needed presence up top. That most likely means Barnes will drop to the bench, with him needing to impress to earn that left-wing spot back.

Newcastle United fans have been left underwhelmed by their team’s performance against Barcelona in the Champions League, with some demanding that a particular player leaves the club immediately.

The match saw Newcastle struggle against the Spanish giants, ultimately losing 2-1.

*Tactical Analysis*

Barcelona’s dominance was evident in their 61% ball possession and 18 shots, 4 of which were on target. Newcastle’s manager, Eddie Howe, had warned his team about the importance of defensive sharpness, particularly on the flanks, to neutralize Barcelona’s attacking threats. However, despite some solid defensive moments, Newcastle’s inability to cope with Barcelona’s relentless pressure ultimately cost them the match.

*Player Spotlight: Anthony Elanga*

Newcastle’s Anthony Elanga impressed with his performance, laying on brilliant chances for Anthony Gordon and Harvey Barnes. Elanga’s pace and agility caused problems for Barcelona’s defense, and his vision and passing range were evident in the chances he created. With a rating of 7, Elanga was one of the standout performers for Newcastle.

*Eddie Howe’s Pre-Match Expectations*

Newcastle United manager Eddie Howe expressed his disappointment about Lamine Yamal’s absence due to injury. “It’s a shame he can’t play. I’m disappointed not to be able to see a player of that level,” Howe stated. Howe emphasized the need for his team to be defensively sharp, particularly on the flanks, to neutralize Barcelona’s attacking threats. Despite the absence of Yamal, Howe’s team showed spirit and determination, but ultimately fell short.

*Post-Match Reaction*

Despite the loss, Newcastle United fans appreciated the team’s effort against one of Europe’s elite clubs. The match was marked by controversy, with a penalty decision sparking debate. Robert Lewandowski converted the penalty, while Miguel Almirón scored a stunning equalizer for Newcastle. The fans recognized the team’s hard work and commitment, and there’s optimism that Newcastle can build on this experience to improve in the future.

*Key Takeaways*

– Newcastle United’s defensive vulnerability was exposed against Barcelona’s attack.
– Anthony Elanga’s performance was a highlight for Newcastle, showcasing his pace and vision.
– Eddie Howe’s team showed spirit and determination, but ultimately fell short against a superior opponent.

*What’s Next for Newcastle United?*

Newcastle United will look to regroup and refocus after their loss to Barcelona. With the Champions League group stage underway, the Magpies will need to quickly put the match behind them and prepare for their next challenge. Can they bounce back and show their true potential? Only time will tell.

In conclusion, Newcastle United’s loss to Barcelona was a tough pill to swallow, but there’s optimism that the team can learn from this experience and improve in the future. With talented players like Anthony Elanga and a committed manager like Eddie Howe, the Magpies have the potential to make a statement in the Champions League.